They don't seem to like the idea of 40-50ish men contacting 28-35 yo women (fertile women) and want to run these off the site to open it up to their true client base - which is older re bounder divorced women.
Its heartbreaking to see a site that is really needed with a moderately large Catholic user base be abused and mis-run like this site is.
There is a possibility that the information provided here is outdated or wrong, please check with the service directly for the most recent information. I'm sure there might be a small percent of good guys but not many.
As always you should read your terms of service before signing up to any online service. I have heard as well that the marriages don't last so don't be fooled by the "success stories" As God said you will know them by their fruits.
Catholic provides a dating service that allows members to be guided by their values and relationship with God, and not with scientific formulas.